Employment Law That Works SM

Justified employee policies to enjoy greater weight, says NLRB

We continue now with our series of deeper dives into a wave of recent decisions by the National Labor Relations Board. As we noted in one recent post, the NLRB reversed a number of rules, specifically targeted were policies that employer advocates felt tilted legal scales toward supporting worker unionizing efforts.

In this post, we intend to examine more closely a decision that overruled an earlier board action that put a crimp on employers' ability to establish certain employee policies - even ones for which an employer might have solid justification. Based on early reaction, it seems businesses feel the move will help avert employee disputes and restore balance to organizing processes protected by law.

The hazards of "reasonable"

In question were Section 7 rights granted to workers seeking to organize under the National Labor Relations Act. The standard at issue was that employers could not include policies in their employer handbooks that might be "reasonably construed" by workers as infringing on their rights to organize.

At issue was a policy of the Boeing Company against using any device to take pictures on company property. The policy did not prohibit employees from discussing employment conditions or engaging in NLRA-protected activities. The indications from case documents are that Boeing was concerned about company security. However, a judge ruled that the policy violated the act because it could be "reasonably construed" as an organizing infringement.

In reversing the policy on a 3-2 vote, the board reversed the judge's decision, saying that the "reasonably construe" standard failed to give weight to Boeing's legitimate concerns. It also said that going forward, its employer policy and handbook reviews would seek to strike more balance in cases where employer justification can be shown.

What does this mean for employers? While more latitude may be given, the key take away is that there must be 'justification' for handbook and other employer policies. Therefore, employers will want to carefully review rules and ensure they have good reasons for their policies that do not otherwise run afoul of NLRB or other agency rules. Kisner Law Firm's experienced employment law attorneys can assist in crafting specialized policies and answer questions about these new rulings.

Categories: Employment Disputes

Kim Kisner, ESQ

Kimberly J. Kisner, Esq.'s Profile Image
Kim Kisner is a Partner with Leech Tishman, and a member of the firm’s Employment, Alternative Dispute Resolution, Litigation and Real Estate Practice Groups. Based in Leech Tishman’s Pittsburgh office, Kim focuses her practice primarily on assis…

Read More About Kim


If you need a competent attorney to help you with wrongful discharge, employment agreements, confidentiality agreements, unemployment compensation claims, employment discrimination issues, workplace and sexual harassment, disability accommodation, Fa…
– Beth Caldwell, Owner and Founder, Pittsburgh Professional Women, LLC, https://ppw.wildapricot.org/

Read More Testimonials

Quick Contact Form

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.